Hi Katie, we appreciate your review and will share with our team for review. Our Eyeliner is ultra-creamy and richly pigmented, for this reason, we recommend using 1/3 of the amount you would typically apply with regular eyeliner. Then, using the built-in smudger you can glide the product across the desired area. This promotes long-wear and gives you a soft-focus look!

Hi Robin, thank you for your review! Our Eyeliner is ultra-creamy and richly pigmented, for this reason, I always say less is more :) I recommend applying 1/3 of the amount you would typically apply with regular eyeliner. Then, using the built-in smudger you can glide the product across the desired area. This promotes long-wear and gives you a soft-focus look!

Hi Rhea, thank you so much for your review! We are so saddened to hear about your experience, especially with our water-resistant Eyeliner. We would love to guide you over to our Beauty Expert, as she can address some of these concerns one-on-one with you! She will send you a private email shortly :)