The pencil eye liner runs but all pencils run for me. I have to use makeup remover to clean it up and really about 1/2 way through the day.

It’s not long wearing and really hard to get a smooth line as it just smudges.

This eyeliner glides on soooooo smoothly! I was so surprised and impressed by how smoothly this applied the first very first time I used this. It's so much better than the drug store brand of eyeliner I've been using for years.

I love how this eyeliner goes without catching and tugging so you can get a smooth continuous line in one go. The built-in smudge sponge is great, too. I'm so thankful the eyeliner, like so many of Trestique's products, is refillable so I can look good and feel good about not creating additional waster when using their products

I ordered this eyeliner in the green color and it is beautiful! It is creamy and long wearing!

I was a forever "black eyeliner" gal from 2002 when I first discovered my love for eyeliner. I can officially say since December 2021 I am officially all about brown eyeliner. I have tried every eyeliner brand you can imagine, and even tried brown liner by other brands in the past, but I can say I never thought I'd make this a staple in my everyday makeup look. I can honestly say, I will never stop buying Swiss Chocolate eyeliner. It makes my hazel eyes pop, I look rested, and I look younger! As a mom looking and feeling great is so important. I am forever thankful for this eyeliner! When I reordered my favorites, I had to pick this as my free gift as I literally travel everywhere with it! This eyeliner also lasts until I take my shower in the evening!!!! I do notice some transfer on the bottom of my lids, so I keep the liner to my top lid.

*I will say, I was unable to reuse this product as the sponge application did fall off prior to purchasing a refill.

I have been on the search for a cream eyeliner/shadow that stays put on my oily eyelids and is highly pigmented. I found it! I wish I’d found Trestique sooner instead of wasting my money on other brands and products that didn’t work for me. I basically won’t be buying any eye products from anywhere else.

I love having the blending brush attached to the eyeliner-makes application so easy! My only note is with oily skin, it makes it smudge fairly quickly.

The black is nice and rich, it also glides on smoothly and the smudger helps for easy touch ups.

I'm not in love with the color of this and unsure on the texture of it. I tested it on my hand and it felt dry, but it might be fine once I get the right color. I will say that Trestique customer service is wonderful, so that's the reason for the review. Thanks!