Hi Leslie, thank you so much for your great feedback! We offer a black shade of Eyeliner named Santorini Black Sand and a deep, rich brown named Swiss Chocolate. Unfortunately, the full size of these two shades is currently out of stock. The good news is that we have the refills available here, so if you go through the Roman Bronze and want to refill with Santorini or Swiss Chocolate, you can do so here: https://www.trestique.com/products/eco-friendly-eyeliner-pencil-refill?variant=39363258417252

Or, we would be happy to notify you when the full size of these is back!

Hi Debra! Thank you so much for your review. I personally love our Eyeliner formula as well ☺️ Yes, this shade (Santorini Black Sand) will be back in stock. You can let us know at hello@trestique.com if you would like to be notified when it's back.

Hi Marissa, thank you for your feedback! Sometimes this can happen if your skincare and/or skin prep is oil-based. If possible, you can allow a few minutes for the skincare to settle in before makeup application. We recommend using a very small amount of product and using the built-in smudger to create a custom look – we hope these tips help!

You can check out our tutorials here: https://www.trestique.com/pages/how-to-use-makeup-products

Please be sure to contact our team at hello@trestique.com with any questions.